Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2005 3:48 pm
hi sara,
this post is being written calmly and without attitude so you can "feel" my intent a little and to prevent reading between the lines as is so easy in these forums.
i would rather have sent this to you personally.
i do hear you saying you had given it thought but i will have to disagree with you about keeping this conversation public, your opinion is very personal and sensitive regarding one person. In that way i feel that it would have been better off not in a public forum that many people access. i used the term 'playground' as i have seen forums before used in this way and i feel this is not being sensitive or appropriate. not all stuff is approriate for public view.
Enabling others to make their own judgements sounds a little like a court hearing to me which this forum is definatly not, we are not here to make judgements on people. this should have been dealt with privatly, its your opinion only and doesnt have place here. Thats my personal feeling on the matter. i understand the point you have made about it.
The reasons why i feel this was inapropriate are as follows-
1. you involved other people in your comment. If someone else has an issue with someone it is their issue to bring up, not for you to use. this was a low blow!
2. I looked hard and could see nothing in Annes posts that would have justified such an attack. It seemed to come from nowhere and you are correct in the thought that it looked very much to me like you’d been storing ‘stuff’ up and waiting for any time where you could offload it to her.
3. It was done publicly, and i have already explained my concrns about this..
4. it seems to be without understanding or evidence- ie- you do not know Anne and forums do not enable you to make those sorts of judgments on people. You should know forums are just words and not “language” so it’s very easy to misunderstand, misrepresent what people say in them. what if you have made an incorrect judgement?
Therefore I felt it was out of order of you to make such a critical judgment, as you cannot make such severe judgments on someone’s character from reading posts in a forum!!
I am not taking sides at all, I know Anne as well as I know you within the confines of this forum! but I do feel strongly enough to write this to you as I feel your attack was unjustified.
i dont always like to play "nice" as its important to be transparent and open, but this needs to be twinned with tact and with minimum ' damage'.
i cant comment on your concern that peoples opinions are being discredited as i have seen no evidence of this. i do know that i have seen anne reply to many posts giving help and advice, as all of us here do.
thanks for posting a reply, i have heard what you have said and you have now read what i have to say.
i will now move on.
this post is being written calmly and without attitude so you can "feel" my intent a little and to prevent reading between the lines as is so easy in these forums.
i would rather have sent this to you personally.
i do hear you saying you had given it thought but i will have to disagree with you about keeping this conversation public, your opinion is very personal and sensitive regarding one person. In that way i feel that it would have been better off not in a public forum that many people access. i used the term 'playground' as i have seen forums before used in this way and i feel this is not being sensitive or appropriate. not all stuff is approriate for public view.
Enabling others to make their own judgements sounds a little like a court hearing to me which this forum is definatly not, we are not here to make judgements on people. this should have been dealt with privatly, its your opinion only and doesnt have place here. Thats my personal feeling on the matter. i understand the point you have made about it.
The reasons why i feel this was inapropriate are as follows-
1. you involved other people in your comment. If someone else has an issue with someone it is their issue to bring up, not for you to use. this was a low blow!
2. I looked hard and could see nothing in Annes posts that would have justified such an attack. It seemed to come from nowhere and you are correct in the thought that it looked very much to me like you’d been storing ‘stuff’ up and waiting for any time where you could offload it to her.
3. It was done publicly, and i have already explained my concrns about this..
4. it seems to be without understanding or evidence- ie- you do not know Anne and forums do not enable you to make those sorts of judgments on people. You should know forums are just words and not “language” so it’s very easy to misunderstand, misrepresent what people say in them. what if you have made an incorrect judgement?
Therefore I felt it was out of order of you to make such a critical judgment, as you cannot make such severe judgments on someone’s character from reading posts in a forum!!
I am not taking sides at all, I know Anne as well as I know you within the confines of this forum! but I do feel strongly enough to write this to you as I feel your attack was unjustified.
i dont always like to play "nice" as its important to be transparent and open, but this needs to be twinned with tact and with minimum ' damage'.
i cant comment on your concern that peoples opinions are being discredited as i have seen no evidence of this. i do know that i have seen anne reply to many posts giving help and advice, as all of us here do.
thanks for posting a reply, i have heard what you have said and you have now read what i have to say.
i will now move on.